Brooklyn (2015)

Brooklyn

When I booked my ticket to see Brooklyn at the Black Night’s Film Festival, I was vaguely aware of what I was going to get myself into. Going in unprepared was probably the right decision because I ended up liking Brooklyn a lot more than I expected. Unexpected was also the level of emotions I got during the movie, and if you would’ve sat next to me, you probably would have heard me mumbling: please don’t, at the very end because I was so afraid of the waterworks.

Brooklyn is a story about Eilis (Saoirse Ronan), a young woman who leaves her mother and sister behind in Ireland, and pursues a life in Brooklyn, New York instead. It’s a bitter sweet story of immigration during the 1950’s, where thousands of Irish people left their country for America, many of them ending up in Brooklyn. Though there is romance in the movie, and a sweet story at that, the immigration theme is definitely the center of Brooklyn and it makes the movie more profound and meaningful.

Based on a novel by Colm Tóibín, Brooklyn was adapted for the screen by Nick Hornby, which was most likely a really good decision. The narrative flowed well, the humor was sophisticated and witty, and though Eilis was the center of the movie, the supportive characters were kept just as important. For instance, despite the main plot taking place in America, we still saw glimpses of Rose, Eilis’ sister, writing back and worth with her sibling. Fiona Glascott, who portrayed Rose, was really good and I was rooting for her from the beginning. The dynamic in their family was interesting on its own as well, and I have a lot of feelings in regards to their mother I don’t even wanna get into it.

Another great supportive character was Eilis’ landlady Mrs. Kehoe, perfectly captured by Julie Walters, who was the right amount of funny and supportive. I especially liked the fact that the story didn’t want to make Mrs. Kehoe the “substitute mother” because that would have been too cliché. The other girls who lived in the house with Eilis were all quite the characters as well and surprisingly, none of them turned out to be mean. Which was ironic, because I’m so used to the cliché of having some character mess up the main relationship, that I’m now surprised when everybody is nice and not a villain.

Anyway, at last, let’s talk about the romance, the aspect which I loved because it was the 50’s, and chivalry was as common as wearing socks. In other words, Tony (Emory Cohen), was lovely, sweet, honorable and a hard working Italian, who liked Irish girls, and he was especially smitten with Eilis. Their love progressed slowly, was adorable and well, Tony’s character was adorable, what can I say. And I loved that Eilis wore shoes that made her taller than Tony! And I loved how she learned how to eat spaghetti when she met his parents. And I loved how he walked her home and.. well, I just loved their story line and its simplicity compared to the romance that seems to be idolized nowadays.

Of course there was some doubt and drama, but it felt natural for Eilis. It sort of felt like what if to her and I guess Jim Farrell (Domhnall Gleeson) represented a different kind of future for our protagonist. The choice between the two, Tony and Jim wasn’t obviously thrown into our face either. Jim was nice as well, and he was in Ireland, while Tony was somewhere in Brooklyn, fixing pipes. I guess what I want to say is, that though I was rooting for Tony all the way, I understand Eilis’ affection towards Jim as well. But whatever the choice, Eilis made it for herself not for others and for all the right reasons.

Advertisements

11 thoughts on “Brooklyn (2015)”

  1. Great review! I really enjoyed this too and I recently finished the book. I think they made Jim a bit more desirable in the movie, because in the novel Eilis actually meets him before she leaves and he’s a total dick. But I can see where familiarity would be appealing to her at that moment in her life. I like how they expanded the ending in the film vs what’s in the book. That was nice.

    1. Oh! I want to read the book now.. was Tony on page as adorable as on screen? I think Cohen did a lovely job and I liked the casting of them two a lot.. they were so different and yet, so compatible!

  2. Great review! I loved the tone of the 50s for sure with the chivalry pouring out everywhere…Ronan’s relationships were quite sweet, but she’s definitely the MVP of this film 🙂 I wish I’d liked it more, but I can admit that we do need more films like this.

  3. I’m quite sad I missed this. It got a short run at my local cinema with all the big blockbusters coming out.

    1. That’s sad.. I luckily saw it before it actually came out here so I would have more chances to see it if would like to. You have to come back to Estonia to see it then. 😀

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s